Talk:Marriage:Eight Forms of Marriage
By Sri Chandrasekharendra Saraswati Swami
The dharmaśāstra-s, including the Manusmṛti, mention eight forms of marriage:
Brahmo-daivastathaivārṣaḥ prājāpatyas tatha' suraḥ Gāndharvo rākṣasaś caiva Paiśācas tamaḥ smṛtaḥ —Manusmṛti 3.21
The eight types are: brāhma, daiva, ārṣa, prājāpatya, āsura, gāndharva, rākṣasa and paiśāca.
After the student-bachelor has completed his gurukulavāsa, his parents approach the parents of a girl from a good family and request them to give away their daughter in marriage to their son—offering her as kanyādāna. A marriage arranged like this is brāhma. In it, the bride’s family gives neither dowry nor ornaments to the groom’s family. There is no “commercial transaction”, and the goal of a brāhma marriage is the dhārmic upliftment of both families. Of all eight types, the dharmaśāstra-s consider this the highest.
Marrying a girl to a ṛtvik (priest) during a sacrifice is called daiva. In this type, the parents, having waited in vain for a suitor, seek a groom at a sacrificial site. This is considered inferior to brāhma because, in śāstric tradition, womanhood is honoured by the expectation that the groom’s family must seek a bride, not vice versa.
The third form, ārṣa, is associated with the ṛṣi-s or sages. For instance, the marriage of Sukanyā to Cyavana Maharṣi seems to be of this type. The dharmaśāstra-s state that in an ārṣa marriage, the bride is given in exchange for two cows. This implies a compromise due to delay in conducting a proper brāhma marriage. The presence of an exchange shows that the groom may not be especially qualified. Noble marriages, as per the śāstra-s, avoid transactions of any kind.
In prājāpatya, there is no trading, and kanyādāna remains essential. However, the name implies that the girl’s menarche is imminent and procreation is expected soon after. Hence, unlike in brāhma, the bride’s father actively searches for a groom. Since in brāhma the groom’s people seek the bride to be their household gṛhalakṣmī, it is considered the superior form.
In the āsura type, the groom is not a suitable match, but the girl’s family receives a large sum from him—effectively compelling them to marry her off. Unlike ārṣa, where cows are gifted without coercion, the āsura groom uses power or wealth. Many wealthy men are thought to have taken second wives through āsura marriages.
The next is gāndharva. This type is the romantic “love marriage” popular today. The classic example is that of Śakuntalā and Duṣyanta.
In the rākṣasa form, the groom engages in battle with the girl’s family, defeats them, and abducts her. Śrī Kṛṣṇa’s marriage to Rukmiṇī is an example. Despite the violence, Rukmiṇī willingly accepted him.
The eighth and lowest form is paiśāca. Here, the girl is seized against her will, her family antagonised, and no compensation given. Her consent is not even considered. Even āsura offers some form of exchange, and in rākṣasa the girl is at least willing. Paiśāca lacks both.
At one end is brāhma marriage; at the other, paiśāca. The same system cannot suit all. The śāstra-s acknowledge differences in nature, social structure, and values, and accordingly prescribe distinct forms of marriage. Much present-day confusion stems from the mistaken notion that one standard should apply to all.
There are tribals living in the forests who look fierce and have a harsh way of life. But at heart they may be more cultured than townspeople, not to speak of the fact that they are useful to society in many ways. They have frequent family feuds. In consideration of this, rākṣasa and paiśāca marriages may have to be permitted in their case. After the marriage, they are likely to forget their quarrels and live in peace with each other.
Kṣatriya-s, who are physically strong and accustomed to material pleasure, are allowed the gāndharva form of marriage. Their girls even have the right to choose their husbands, as in the svayaṁvara ceremony.
It is for these reasons that the dharmaśāstra-s—which are based on the Veda-s and constitute Hindu law—permit eight forms of marriage. In all these eight, the bride and groom have the right to be united in wedlock with the chanting of mantra-s. But brāhma is the highest of the eight forms. In it, the bride must not have attained puberty. Pradānaṁ prakṛtauḥ—this statement is found in the dharmaśāstra-s themselves. A girl’s marriage, which holds the same significance for her as upanayana does for a boy, must be performed when she is seven years old (or eight years from conception).
Unfortunately, in the case of some girls, a groom does not turn up in time for a brāhma marriage to be performed. Meanwhile, they grow older and their marriage is conducted in the ārṣa, daiva, or prājāpatya way. Only these types are permitted for Brāhmaṇa-s. But for others, the remaining types are also allowed. They may marry a girl who has come of age either in the gāndharva way or in a svayaṁvara.
The marriage mantra-s are intended for all the eight forms. That means they are used even in the marriage of girls who have attained puberty. The two mantra-s quoted earlier are recited in all eight types of marriage. They are addressed by the groom to the bride, who comes to him after having attained puberty and after having been under the guardianship successively of Soma, the gandharva, and Agni. These mantra-s are not only used in brāhma marriages but also in all other forms. The groom addresses them even to a child bride. Though the marriage is solemnised now, he will start living with her only after she comes of age—after she passes under Soma, the gandharva, and Agni. So he chants the mantra-s in advance.
Nowadays we sometimes perform a number of saṁskāra-s together long after they are due according to the śāstra-s. For example, we perform the jātakarma of a son, along with his nāmakaraṇa and cūḍākaraṇa, during his upanayana at the age of 20 or 22—not long before his marriage. Similarly, in brāhma marriage, instead of postponing the rites, the mantra-s are chanted in advance.
Here is an example in this context. When a brahmacārin performs samid-ādhāna, he prays to Agni to grant him good children. How absurd would it be if reformers argued, based on this prayer, that a boy must have children while he is still a celibate student and only later become a householder! The point to understand is that the boy prays in advance for good children. The Vedic mantra-s cited by the reformers must be seen in the same light.
The mantra-s [quoted by reformers] are appropriate for the marriage of a girl who has come of age also.
This is our reply to the school of opinion represented by the Rt Hon’ble Śrīnivāsa Śāstrī. If the mantra-s in question are chanted at the time of the marriage of girls who have come of age, it does not mean that all marriages must be celebrated after puberty. According to the brāhma form of marriage, the girl must not have had her menarche. There is incontrovertible proof of this in the Vedic mantra chanted at the end of the marriage rite.
I told you that a girl is under the sway of a gandharva between the time she is able to wear her clothes without anybody's help and her menarche. His name is Viśvāvasu. The mantra I referred to is chanted by the groom addressing this demigod: "O Viśvāvasu, I bow to you. Leave this girl and go. Go to another girl child. Have I not become the husband of this girl? So give her over to me and go to another girl who is not married and lives with her father."
During the wedding, the groom performs a pūjā to this gandharva and prays to him to free the girl from his control. Here is proof that the bride is not under Agni and has not had her menarche.
The question now is about the verse from the Manusmṛti cited by the reformists. According to it, a girl may wait three years after her menarche and then seek her husband on her own.
There is an answer to this. The general rule according to the dharmaśāstra-s is that a girl must be married before she attains puberty: Pradānaṁ prakṛtauḥ — “The giving away (of the girl) must be before (her) menstruation.”
What happens if this injunction is not followed? If a groom does not come on his own, seeking the girl's hand, her father or brother must look for a groom and marry her off. But what if they turn out to be irresponsible or otherwise fail in their duty? Or if the girl has no guardian, no one to care for her? The lines quoted by the reformers from the Manusmṛti apply to such a girl. She may look for a husband on her own if none of her relatives, neighbours, or well-wishers take the trouble of finding her a groom even after she has attained puberty.
Though the reformists quote from the Veda-s and śāstra-s in support of their view, they fail to take into account the context in which the relevant passages occur. They interpret them in isolation. That is why they keep arguing that the customs followed by people steeped in our traditions are contrary to the śāstra-s.
In the Chāndogya Upaniṣad, there is mention of a sage called Cakrayāṇa Uśasti whose wife had not come of age. The reformists do not examine such references in our ancient texts with a cool head but are carried away by emotion.
In the past, common people did not know how to counter the arguments of the reformists. Even so, they did not accept their views, thinking it best to follow the practices of their elders—of great men. That is why the bill brought twice by the Rt Hon’ble Śrīnivāsa Śāstrī before the legislative council to amend the marriage act (with reference to the age of marriage) did not receive enough support. Later, Haribilās Śarda introduced the bill which, upon passage, came to be called the Śarda Act. Many people (especially in the South) think Śarda was a woman and call the law named after him the “Śarda Act”.
The Central Legislative Assembly was equally divided on the bill—50 percent for and 50 percent against. Then the British asked one of the nominated members to vote in favour of the bill, and thus the minimum age of marriage for girls was raised by legal enactment. The bill was passed not on the strength of public opinion but due to government intervention. The thinking of the British rulers was: “The Congress has been demanding svarāj, but we have refused to grant it. Let us give it some satisfaction by helping to inflict an injury on the (Hindu) religion.”
Now things have changed. There is no longer respect for old customs and traditions. When the Śarda Act came into force in British India, some Sanskrit scholars returned the title of Mahāmahopādhyāya conferred on them by the government. Among them were Pañcānana Tarkaratna Bhaṭṭācārya of Bengal and Lakṣmaṇa Śāstrī Draviḍ. The latter was settled in Kāśī and carried the tag “Draviḍ” to indicate that he belonged to the Tamil region.
How many people today are inspired to rise in protest against the changes introduced by our government in our śāstric observances?
Our children must be taught the substance and meaning of the śāstra-s in a comprehensive manner. To speak to them about one aspect here and another there will only lead to a haphazard and confused view. The half-baked research being done in the Veda-s has given rise to the opinion that the scriptures favour love marriage. The canonical texts must be studied in their entirety. When a subject is examined, its underlying meaning and purpose must be grasped. They must also be viewed in light of other relevant passages occurring elsewhere. Only after a thorough and contextual inquiry should conclusions be drawn.
The brāhma marriage is valid for all castes. Other forms of marriage are also permitted for non-Brāhmaṇa-s, including post-puberty marriages. If the intent is to give importance to carnal pleasure, these other forms may be accepted. But brāhma is the best if the purpose of the marriage saṁskāra is the advancement of the Self.
